The Screening Phone Interview: Your First Line of Defense in Recruiting
The phone interview is often the first real interaction between your company and a potential hire, making it a crucial step in the recruiting process.
A quick message from us at Pegasus:
Emerging Angel Program
Break the mold and dive into angel investing with a fresh perspective. Our Emerging Angel Program provides a comprehensive curriculum on innovative investment strategies, unique deal sourcing, and hands-on, real-world experiences, all guided by industry experts.
The phone interview is often the first real interaction between your company and a potential hire, making it a crucial step in the recruiting process. It’s your opportunity to quickly assess whether a candidate has the basic qualifications, experience, and cultural fit before investing more time and resources into the full interview process. While it’s a relatively brief interaction, mastering the phone interview can save you countless hours and help you identify the candidates most likely to succeed in your organization.
You’d be surprised at what people will reveal during a screening interview. As someone who has interviewed countless candidates, I’ve seen everything from well-prepared responses to outright disastrous answers. Following a structured model can help you quickly screen out candidates who raise red flags and identify those worth investing more time in.
Here’s how to effectively screen candidates through a structured and intentional phone interview, along with the critical questions you should be asking.
1. Setting Clear Objectives for the Phone Interview
Before jumping on the call, it’s essential to define what you want to accomplish on the phone screen. Are you looking to verify their technical skills? Gauge their cultural fit? Assess their communication abilities? Having a clear purpose will guide your questioning and help you stay focused.
Key Areas to Evaluate:
• Basic Qualifications: Ensure the candidate meets the minimum requirements for the role, such as specific skills, experience, or certifications.
• Communication Skills: Can they articulate their experience, ideas, and motivations clearly? This is especially important for roles requiring frequent interaction with clients, stakeholders, or team members.
• Cultural Alignment: While cultural fit will be assessed more deeply later in the process, the phone screen can provide early insights into whether the candidate aligns with your company’s values and work environment.
Pro Tip: Create a phone interview template with the key areas you want to cover. This ensures consistency across all candidates and makes it easier to compare notes afterward.
2. Structuring the Call: Creating a Consistent Process
It's crucial to have a well-organized structure to make the most of the limited time you have during a phone interview (typically 20–30 minutes). This ensures you cover all the necessary points and helps create a positive experience for the candidate.
Recommended Phone Interview Structure:
1. Introduction (2–3 minutes): Start by introducing yourself, your role, and a brief overview of the company. Set expectations for the call, including how long it will take and what you hope to achieve.
2. Candidate’s Background (5–7 minutes): Ask the candidate to walk you through their experience, focusing on how it relates to the position. Listen for consistency, clarity, and enthusiasm.
3. Role-Specific Questions (10–12 minutes): This is the core of the interview. Ask targeted questions related to the skills and experience required for the role. Use behavioral questions to uncover how they’ve handled similar challenges in the past.
4. Cultural Fit Questions (5 minutes): Gauge the candidate’s alignment with your company values by asking about their preferred work environment, team dynamics, and career goals.
5. Candidate’s Questions (3–5 minutes): Allow the candidate to ask questions. This not only shows that you value their curiosity but also provides insight into what they prioritize in a job.
Example Questions to Integrate:
• “What do you expect to gain from working at a startup?” This question is essential because working at a startup isn’t for everyone. It involves longer hours, more stress, and a chaotic environment. Understanding their motivation for wanting to work in such an environment will help you assess if they’re prepared for the challenges and whether they’ll thrive in your culture.
• “What are your most significant accomplishments, and what do you enjoy doing professionally?” This question is a subtle way of getting candidates to talk about their strengths. Let them explore this question in detail; it will provide you with insight into where they truly shine and how they might fit into your team.
Pro Tip: Allow the candidate to elaborate freely on these questions, and we encourage you to ask them more than four times. While they might have the first response prepared, their subsequent answers will help distinguish the top performers from those less suitable.
3. Identifying Red Flags Early On
The phone interview is an excellent opportunity to identify potential red flags that might disqualify a candidate. These could include inconsistencies in experience, an inability to articulate skills, or a lack of enthusiasm for the role.
Questions to Expose Potential Red Flags:
• “What are you not interested in doing professionally, or what are you not good at?” Instead of asking the typical “greatest weakness” question (which often results in a rehearsed answer), this phrasing is more disarming and encourages honesty. If the candidate is hesitant to admit weaknesses, follow up with, “If you move on to the next round, we’ll be asking you to set up references with peers, previous employers, and co-workers. What do you think they would say you’re not good at?” This often prompts a more genuine response.
Pro Tip: A-players are comfortable discussing their weaknesses and will often describe how they’re working to improve. It’s far more valuable to hire someone who recognizes and addresses their shortcomings than someone who doesn’t know or isn’t willing to work on them.
4. Probing Techniques: The Power of ‘What,’ ‘How,’ and ‘Tell Me More’
One of the reasons sales skills are so valuable is their applicability in every facet of life—including interviewing. When a candidate gives you an answer, don’t just accept it at face value. Use probing questions like:
• “What do you mean by that?”
• “How did that make you feel?”
• “Tell me more about that particular situation.”
These prompts encourage candidates to provide more detailed responses, allowing you to uncover more profound insights into their thought processes, experiences, and attitudes.
Pro Tip: The more you probe, the more you’ll understand whether this candidate has the depth and experience required for the role. Spend additional time with candidates who demonstrate strong potential, but don’t hesitate to end the call early with those who raise multiple red flags.
5. Ending the Call Professionally and Next Steps
At the end of the call, thank the candidate for their time and provide information about the next steps in the hiring process. If you plan to move forward, let them know when they can expect to hear from you. If they’re not a fit, be polite and respectful—how you handle this part of the process reflects your company’s reputation.
Pro Tip: Take detailed notes immediately after the call while the conversation is still fresh in your mind. This will make comparing candidates easier and help you make more informed decisions as you move forward.
6. Evaluating and Shortlisting Candidates
Once you’ve completed the phone interview, it’s time to evaluate whether the candidate should advance to the next stage. Create a standardized scoring system to rate each candidate based on criteria such as skills, communication, enthusiasm, and cultural fit. This system will help you remain objective and consistent throughout the hiring process.
Key Evaluation Criteria:
• Technical Skills: Did they demonstrate the skills and experience required for the role?
• Communication: Were they articulate, confident, and clear in their responses?
• Cultural Fit: Do they align with your company’s values and work style?
Pro Tip: Discuss your evaluations with other team members involved in the hiring process to gain different perspectives before making a final decision.
Final Thoughts: Mastering the Phone Interview
The phone interview is crucial in building a solid foundation for your recruiting process. By approaching it with structure, intention, and clear objectives, you can screen candidates effectively and identify those most likely to thrive in your organization. Remember, the goal isn’t just to find someone who can do the job—it’s to find someone who will contribute to your team’s success and growth.
Key Takeaways:
• Prepare with Clear Objectives: Know what you want to accomplish during the call and have a structured plan.
• Listen Actively: The phone interview is about learning as much as possible about the candidate, so let them do most of the talking.
• Identify Red Flags: Pay attention to inconsistencies, negative attitudes, or a lack of enthusiasm.
• End with Professionalism: Provide clarity on the next steps and leave a positive impression, regardless of the outcome.
Learn More
Visit us at pegasusangelaccelerator.com
Venture Fellow Program
Designed for aspiring venture capitalists and startup leaders, our Venture Fellow Program offers deep insights into venture operations, fund management, and growth strategies, all guided by seasoned industry experts.
Emerging Angel Program
Break the mold and dive into angel investing with a fresh perspective. Our Emerging Angel Program provides a comprehensive curriculum on innovative investment strategies, unique deal sourcing, and hands-on, real-world experiences, all guided by industry experts.
For Founders
Pegasus offers two exclusive programs tailored to help startups succeed—whether you're raising capital or need help with sales, we’ve got you covered.
Accelerate
To help startups raise capital and expand networks. We invest $100K twice a year in 12-week cohorts, providing access to 850+ mentors and invaluable industry connections.
Ascend
To help startups master sales and GTM strategies. Achieve 5x valuation growth and 1,253% mRR growth, with access to $1M in perks to scale your success.
Apply now to join an exclusive group of high-potential startups!
🚀